Yep Dan, it was never my intention to mislead newbies. I was just sharing information on the conditions needed to lead to the possible weaning of such fish. Such as the appropriate foods, the right environment, and the right companion fishes.
I'm keeping mandarins without liverock but I have alot of rubble. Then again, my tanks are all high nutrient tanks with tonnes of copepods/amphipods. No huge boisterous fish are kept with them. The mandarins themselves are the largest fish in my tanks.
I personally find that in most reef tanks, reefers are fearful of overfeeding and they do all sort of things to eliminate diatoms, which is essential to have a healthy population of copepods.
Yep, only my spotted mandarin is weaned for now. The common mandarin is not weaned yet but is still fat on a diet of pods. Maybe the spotted mandarin is easier to wean just like how scooter dragonets are easier to wean compared to mandarins? I'll need to do more 'experiments'. In the meantime will be looking for one more spotted and one more normal mandarin for observation purposes. It would be good to find out which mandarin is easier to wean would'nt it?