wow. Im amazed that this is even a question offered.
skimmer is basic equipment required to run a salt water fish tank. Im from australia, work in an aquarium store, and cant believe that people would sell a marine set up with out a skimmer.
any fish, or other live stock (corals, inverts, etc) require nutrients to survive in an aquarium. These live stock will produce protein as a waste of the food they eat in the form of protein. Protein skimmers remove this waste, as well as excess phosphate (that cause major algae problems) and are a must for any sustainable salt water aquarium.
The only exception is if you do weekly (at least once a week if not twice a week) water changes of 10-20% to manually remove this waste.
I know that aquariums can be run without skimmer but for the money spent on coral and fish ($20-100+ ea) the small investment of even a cheap skimmer costing $100 can and WILL save you $100's if you wish to run a successful aquarium in the long run and not have fish and coral die.
Correct skimmer, lighting and live rock will ensure you have a marine aquarium for the long term (1yr+)!!!
Im a reefer since 2008 and have had fresh water since 1998. Have had 8x2x2ft reef and currently run a newly set up 3x18x18inch mixed reef.
scrubbers are good at removing some waste but I have seen time and time again aquarium that run very well without scrubbers but not aquariums that run without skimmer. The more you can spend on a skimmer the better. SKIMS singapore are top of the range and well worth the dollars spent.
please look at the poll and buy a skimmer. scrubber is worth looking at in the future if you really need but skimmer is a MUST!!!!!!
hope my experience helps. here a pic of my tank. no scrubber but nice big skimmer....
check out www.masa.asn.au tank journals. almost none have scrubbers but almost ALL have skimmers.