The age old battle: legitimacy, natural vs unnatural
None of that applies here, we are for the desperate or the prevention of the desperate
any other method should be considered first if you wrestle with natural vs unnatural methods, whats acceptable and not acceptable to use.
All we do is fix tanks, period
sometimes peroxide threads come down to this: bandaid
we talk about that too in the thread. there is a reason the thread keeps getting used by scores of people even though I dont post in it anymore, outcome.
maybe something better will come along and this will stop being used, but I dont think so
its good to detract anything and see if it stands a test. pick any one of our cure tanks you'd have fixed a different way, and lets discuss and make predictions about how that w go down this is always good science discussion material
In time I noticed that nobody can tell you to use peroxide, or ATS Santa Monica methods, or GFO, or refugiums, or DSB's, or UNLS systems as a "best" way
as long as successful tanks using all these methods exist, all that means is you have a salad bar choice on how to beat your algae problems. Each has pros and cons, a blend of one or more methods is often powerful
the fact is peroxide works, long term, and we can control and predict what it does, its not haphazard. its limitations and benefits are outlined, see if your problem tank can beat my challenge. at the end of the 4 years, I call 90% fixed.